Bankruptcy Attorney San Diego

Wells Fargo $185M Forbearance Settlement: A Look Back

In December 2024, a federal judge in Ohio gave final approval to a $185 million class action settlement with Wells Fargo over COVID-19 mortgage forbearances that borrowers say they never agreed to. Roughly 376,000 class members were covered. Ahren A. Tiller of BLC Law Center, APC is listed on the court’s docket as an attorney for the plaintiffs. This post looks back at what the case was about, what the court decided, and what it means for California homeowners and people considering bankruptcy.

If you are looking for claim deadlines and payment details, see our earlier guide, Wells Fargo COVID Forbearance Settlement: What You Need to Know, and our announcement on helping San Diego residents navigate the settlement.

Background: Forbearance Was Supposed to Be the Borrower’s Choice

When the pandemic hit in March 2020, Congress passed the CARES Act. For federally backed mortgage loans, the law framed forbearance as something the homeowner asks for. Under 15 U.S.C. § 9056(b)(1), a borrower with a COVID-related hardship “may request forbearance” by “submitting a request to the borrower’s servicer” and affirming the hardship. Once a borrower asked, the forbearance was to be granted for up to 180 days, with up to another 180 days available “at the request of the borrower.”

Forbearance pauses mortgage payments, but it is not free money. The skipped payments still have to be dealt with later, and a forbearance can show up when a lender reviews your credit or mortgage history. That is why consent matters.

The Issue: Forbearances Without Informed Consent

The class action alleged that Wells Fargo placed some customers’ mortgages into COVID forbearance without their informed consent, for example after a customer merely asked a question or mentioned a hardship. According to the court’s opinion, the common questions in the case included whether Wells Fargo “negligently or intentionally enrolled customers in forbearance programs without their consent,” whether it breached terms implied in its contracts, and whether its conduct violated consumer protection statutes.

The litigation began in the Northern District of California (No. 3:20-cv-06009). In February 2024, at the parties’ request, the consolidated case and related cases were transferred to the Southern District of Ohio for settlement, where it became In re Wells Fargo COVID Forbearance Settlement Litigation, No. 2:24-cv-01026.

Wells Fargo denied wrongdoing. The final approval order states that the settlement is not an admission of liability or of the truth of the allegations.

The Holding: Final Approval of a $185 Million Settlement

On December 19, 2024, U.S. District Judge Michael H. Watson granted final approval in In re Wells Fargo COVID Forbearance Settlement Litigation, No. 2:24-cv-1026 (S.D. Ohio Dec. 19, 2024) (ECF No. 285). A final judgment was entered on January 15, 2025.

Under Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 23(e)(2), a court may approve a class settlement only after a hearing and on a finding that it is “fair, reasonable, and adequate.” Judge Watson made that finding, concluding that “the Settlement provides a substantial benefit to the Parties and is fair, reasonable, and adequate.” The court also described the deal as the product of “arm’s-length, well-researched, and protracted negotiations” conducted with a retired judge serving as mediator.

What the settlement provides

  • A $185 million settlement fund.
  • Automatic payments funded by a $69 million allocation, paid to class members who did not opt out, with no claim form required. The court noted the automatic payment was expected to be approximately $252 per mortgage.
  • An additional $83.33 automatically for each qualifying co-borrower.
  • Additional compensation by claim for individualized harm caused by the forbearance, such as delayed or more expensive refinancing, denied or reduced credit lines, lost income, or other damages, with supporting evidence.

The class response was notably one-sided. As the court put it, “from a pool of almost 400,000 Class Members, none objected and only 27 have opted out after 99% received notice.”

Why It Matters for California Homeowners

A few lessons from this case apply well beyond Wells Fargo:

  • Read every servicer letter and check your credit reports. Many borrowers learned about an unwanted forbearance only when they applied to refinance or for new credit. Free reports are available at AnnualCreditReport.com.
  • Consent is the line. A servicer changing the status of your loan without your agreement can create real costs. Keep notes of every call, and confirm important requests in writing.
  • Document the harm. This settlement paid more to people who could show specific losses, such as a denied refinance or a higher rate. Good records make claims possible.
  • Bankruptcy status affected class membership. The class definition excluded anyone who was a debtor, or the co-borrower of a debtor, in a Chapter 13 case on the date the mortgage was placed into forbearance. If you were in Chapter 13 at the time, your rights ran through a different path, and it is worth asking a bankruptcy attorney how a servicer’s actions affected your plan.

If mortgage trouble has you behind on payments now, forbearance is not your only option. A Chapter 13 bankruptcy can let you catch up on missed payments over three to five years, and our stop home foreclosure page explains how the automatic stay works.

How BLC Was Involved

The federal court docket lists Ahren A. Tiller of BLC Law Center, APC as an attorney for the plaintiffs. A declaration from Mr. Tiller was also filed as an exhibit in support of plaintiffs’ counsel’s October 2024 motion for attorney fees, litigation expenses, and class representative service awards (ECF No. 252). The case was the work of many firms, and lead counsel roles were held by other attorneys. The allocation of fees among plaintiffs’ firms was referred to a special master, who issued a report and recommendation in April 2026. Lawyer Monthly reported on the settlement in November 2024.

For BLC, the case reflects a theme in our consumer practice: holding lenders and servicers to the rules that protect borrowers. Learn more about attorney Ahren Tiller.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can I still file a claim in the Wells Fargo forbearance settlement?

No. The claim, opt-out and objection deadlines have passed, and the court entered final judgment in January 2025. Class members who did not opt out were eligible for the automatic payment. See our settlement guide for details.

Did Wells Fargo admit wrongdoing?

No. Wells Fargo denied the allegations, and the final approval order states that the settlement is not an admission of liability or evidence of wrongdoing.

I was in Chapter 13 when Wells Fargo put my loan into forbearance. Was I in the class?

Under the class definition, people who were debtors, or co-borrowers of debtors, in a Chapter 13 case on the date the mortgage was placed into forbearance were excluded. If that describes you, talk to a bankruptcy attorney about your situation.

Can a mortgage servicer put my loan into forbearance without asking me?

For federally backed loans, the CARES Act framed COVID forbearance as something the borrower requests. Whether a particular servicer action was lawful depends on your loan and the facts, so keep records and get advice if your loan status changed without your agreement.

Does a forbearance affect a bankruptcy case?

It can. Missed or deferred mortgage payments may need to be addressed in a Chapter 13 plan, and they matter when deciding whether to keep a home in Chapter 7. A consultation can help sort this out.

Talk to a San Diego Bankruptcy Attorney

If a lender or servicer has made a mess of your mortgage, or you are falling behind and want to keep your home, call Bankruptcy Law Center at 800-551-7922 for a free consultation. You can also learn about Chapter 7 bankruptcy in San Diego.

Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome.

This article is general information, not legal advice.

Related Articles

See What Our Clients Have To Say

Ready To Eliminate Your Debt?

Bankruptcy is still the best option. Other debt plans make promises, but only bankruptcy delivers. Free consultations and affordable payment plans starting at just $100 down.

FREE CASE EVALUATION 

Consent
Bankruptcy Law Center

SAN DIEGO OFFICE

1230 Columbia St. #1100 San Diego, CA 92101

LOS ANGELES OFFICE

11500 Olympic Blvd., 4th Floor Los Angeles, CA 90064

VISTA OFFICE

380 South Melrose Drive #308 Vista, CA 92081

Legal Disclaimer: The Bankruptcy Law Center is a California Licensed law firm with attorneys licensed in the state of CA. Attorney Ahren Tiller is responsible for this advertisement. Bankruptcy Law Center’s principal office is located at 1230 Columbia St. Suite 1100 San Diego, CA 92101. Prior results listed on this site do not depict or in any way infer a prediction or outcome. Bankruptcy Law Center is a debt relief agency proudly providing options to people with financial problems. View our Privacy Policy and Our Terms and Conditions. 

© 2026 All Rights Reserved.

Existing clients: Client Portal login